Skip to content

PID control versus a simple thermostat

Last checked November 18, 2026

A simple thermostat has two settings: heater on, heater off. A PID has many in between. That one difference explains much of what people mean by "better temperature control."

How the simple thermostat works

A thermostat keeps a temperature by "switching heating or cooling devices on or off". Wikipedia calls conventional ones "bang-bang controllers" because the system "either operates at full capacity once the setpoint is reached, or keeps completely off".1

How an on/off thermostat behavesWater cools below the set pointHeater switches fully onWater passes the set pointHeater switches fully off
The heater is either fully on or fully off.

To stop the switch from clicking on and off too fast, the design needs some built-in slack. Wikipedia says the result is that "conventional thermostats cannot control temperatures very precisely." It adds a general figure for conventional thermostats, "usually 1-2 °C". That is not a measured figure for an espresso machine's brew water, and the source marks it "citation needed".1

Many thermostats use a bimetallic strip, which bends as it changes temperature. Electronic ones use a thermistor or similar sensor instead.1

How the PID differs

A PID also compares the target with the measured value. But it doesn't just ask "above or below?" It looks at how big the gap is. It looks at how long the gap has lasted. It looks at how fast the gap is changing. Then it picks a heater output.2

The derivative part is the one aimed at overshoot. Wikipedia says it "reduces overshoot", which means the water running hotter than the target before it settles. Thermostats fight overshoot too. Some include an "anticipator" that switches off slightly early.21

The thermostat page says "When higher control precision is required, a PID or MPC controller is preferred." It adds that they are "nowadays mainly adopted for industrial purposes".1

Side by side

Simple thermostat PID controller
Heater output Fully on or fully off1 Adjusted by the size of the gap, its history and its trend2
Typical swing Wikipedia gives 1-2 °C as a general figure for conventional thermostats, not for espresso machines1 Aims to hold close to the target and reduce overshoot2
Display Often none, or a dial Usually a number you can read and change
Suits Someone who wants a plain, simple machine Someone who wants to see and set a target temperature

The last two rows describe how machines are commonly built, not a rule. Check your maker's manual for how your own machine behaves.

Does a PID make better coffee?

Nothing on this page says so, and a number on a display can't tell you. A steadier water temperature is one thing. Taste is another, and it also depends on the beans, the grind and more. This site sticks to how the control works.

What a PID does give you is a target you can see and change, and a heater that's managed more finely. If your machine has a plain thermostat, that's not a fault. It's a different design.

Which suits whom

A plain thermostat suits someone who wants few controls and doesn't mind a small swing in temperature. A PID suits someone who likes to read a number and change it. Neither choice says anything about whether the coffee will taste better. Read your own manual to see which design you have, and what the maker says about its settings.

Both designs rely on a sensor. Sensors come next.

Cited material

  1. Thermostat, Wikipedia
  2. Proportional–integral–derivative controller, Wikipedia